Richardson LoansSan Diego · Orange · Riverside

Blog

He had to sell his house to buy the one he wanted. Then he didn't.

A buyer turned his departing home into a rental and made a non-contingent offer against five competitors. How Fannie Mae's September 2026 rental income change works, and when it helps.

He wasn't house hunting that weekend. He followed an open house sign off the main road, walked through the door, and that was that. The problem showed up about four minutes later, when the agent mentioned the offers already in hand.

He owned a home, and he'd only talked to his bank. He came away from that conversation believing his offer would have to be contingent on selling, and that sellers sitting on multiple offers don't pick the contingent one.

So he went home assuming it was over. His agent suggested he call me first.

What “contingent” actually costs you

A contingent offer asks the seller to take the house off the market and wait while you sell yours. From the seller's side that's a bet on someone else's buyer, someone else's inspection, someone else's lender. When there's one offer on the table, sellers take that bet. When there are five, they don't have to.

That's the whole problem. Not the money. The sequence.

The options people usually hear first

Most buyers in this spot get offered one of three things.

A bridge loan, which works and is expensive, and which you're paying for during exactly the stretch where you own two houses.

A contingency with a tight deadline, which is still a contingency. Shortening it doesn't change what the seller is being asked to accept.

Or sell first and rent in between, which removes the problem entirely and also means moving twice and house hunting without a home.

None of those are wrong. They just weren't the cheapest path here.

The plan

Two moves, and neither was clever. They were just available.

First, we pulled equity out of his current home to cover the down payment on the new one. That answered the cash question without waiting on a sale.

Second, his departing residence became a rental instead of a listing. That changed what the lender had to count against him, and it's the piece most buyers in his position don't know is on the table.

With both in place, his offer went in non-contingent. Same buyer, same house, same money, and a completely different-looking offer.

The Fannie Mae change that made the second part work

Fannie Mae updated how a departing residence is treated in September 2026, and it matters for anyone planning to keep their current home and rent it out.

The lender establishes a fair market rent for your current home. That can come from a full appraisal with market rents, from a rent survey on Form 1007, or from a market analysis tool backed by at least three comparable rentals. One thing that is specifically off the table is a lease. A signed tenant doesn't substitute for the market rent, which catches out people who went and found a renter thinking it would help.

Then the arithmetic. Take 75% of that market rent, then subtract the full housing payment on the departing residence, including taxes, insurance and any association dues. If what's left is positive, it offsets that property's payment. If it's negative, the shortfall counts against your debt-to-income.

That distinction is the one to hold onto. The 75% isn't a credit against your payment. It's the opening number in a subtraction, and whether the result helps you depends on how your current payment compares to what the place rents for. For someone with an older, lower payment on a house in a strong rental market, the math tends to work. For someone who bought recently at a higher payment, it can go the other way.

The part that isn't underwriting

I called the listing agent. Then I called her again.

She had five offers and no particular reason to trust a plan she hadn't seen work. So I walked her through it, told her what would happen and when, and kept telling her as each piece landed. By the time we were in escrow she knew more about that file than most agents know about their own buyers.

Sellers don't accept offers. People do, and they accept the one they believe will close.

Where it landed

Thirty days. He has the house he followed a sign to, and a rental property in San Diego he wasn't planning on owning.

The rental wasn't the goal. It was the mechanism. He just happens to have kept it.

Whether this works for you

It comes down to three things, and you can get a rough read on all of them before you talk to anyone.

How much equity is in your current home, which decides whether the down payment is there.

What your current home would rent for against what you're paying on it, which decides whether the departing residence helps or hurts.

What you can carry if the rental sits empty for a stretch, because a plan that only works at full occupancy isn't a plan.

If the numbers look close, that's worth a conversation. Close is where the structure matters most.

Buying before you sell? Tell me what you own and what you are looking at, and I will tell you whether the non-contingent version works. → Get in touch

Guidelines change and lender overlays vary. The figures above reflect Fannie Mae's September 2026 treatment of departing residence rental income. Your own numbers should be confirmed before you write an offer.

Nick Richardson · Mortgage Broker · NMLS 966361 · Prime Investment Financial, Inc. NMLS 2460565 · Equal Housing Opportunity
Licensing · Privacy · richardsonloans.com